> For the complete documentation index, see [llms.txt](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/llms.txt). Markdown versions of documentation pages are available by appending `.md` to page URLs; this page is available as [Markdown](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/green-star-buildings/v1.0-rev-c/categories-and-credits/responsible/3-or-verification-and-handover.md).

# 3 | Verification and Handover

Points: 1

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Outcome</mark>

The building has been optimised and handed over to deliver a high level of performance in operation.

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Criteria</mark>

<mark style="color:$success;">**Minimum Expectation — Nil**</mark>

* [#id-3.0.1-metering-and-monitoring](#id-3.0.1-metering-and-monitoring "mention")**:** The building is set up for optimum ongoing management due to its appropriate metering and monitoring systems.
* [#id-3.0.2-commissioning-and-tuning](#id-3.0.2-commissioning-and-tuning "mention")**:** The building has set environmental performance targets, designed and tested for airtightness, been commissioned, and will be tuned.
* [#id-3.0.3-building-information](#id-3.0.3-building-information "mention")**:** The project team create and deliver operations and maintenance information to the facilities management team at the time of handover. Information is available to building users on how to best use the building.

<mark style="color:$success;">**Credit Achievement — 1 point**</mark>

In addition to the *Minimum Expectation*:

* [#id-3.1.1-independent-commissioning-agent](#id-3.1.1-independent-commissioning-agent "mention")**:** An independent level of verification is provided to the design, planning, commissioning and tuning activities through the involvement of an independent commissioning agent.

or

* [#id-3.1.2-soft-landings-approach](#id-3.1.2-soft-landings-approach "mention")**:** The project uses a soft landings approach that involves the future facilities management team.

For large projects, both must occur.

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Additional information</mark>

#### Stage implementation

Strategy | Brief | Concept | **Design** | **Tender** | **Construction** | **Handover** | **Use**

#### Synergies with other credits

* Energy Use
* Energy Source
* Grid Resilience
* Operations Resilience
* Clean Air

#### Sustainable Development Goals

* **Goal 11:** Sustainable Cities

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Requirements</mark>

### <mark style="color:$success;">Minimum Expectation</mark>

The project must comply with all three of the following criteria:

* Metering and Monitoring
* Commissioning and Tuning
* Building Information

#### 3.0.1 Metering and Monitoring

#### *Metering*

The building must have accessible energy and water metering for all common uses, major uses, and major sources.

The meters must be connected to a monitoring system capable of capturing and processing the data produced by the meters.

The meters and automatic monitoring systems must:

* Provide continual information (up to 1-hour interval readings)
* Be commissioned and validated per the most current 'Validating Non-Utility Meters for NABERS Ratings' protocol to support future achievement of a NABERS rating, irrespective of the current viability of a NABERS rating for the building or building type
* Ensure all meters including utility meters and sub-meters to have accuracy declarations and/or certificates (for an example Utility Meters will have certificates issued by the National Measurement Institute)
* Sub-meters that are not to be used as utility (billing) meters should either have Certificates for accuracy issued by NMI or a test certificate from the European Measuring Instruments Directive - 2004/22/CE
* Where the building's Gross Floor Area (excluding car parking areas) is smaller than 1000m², unless specialist equipment with an annual power consumption of 100kwh/annum, is present in the building, a single meter for energy and a single meter for water will comply with this minimum requirement. If accessible to the building manager, the utility meter is acceptable provided it meets accuracy and data collection requirements above.

#### *Monitoring strategy*

The monitoring system must accurately and clearly present the metered data and include reports on consumption trends for the automatic monitoring system. The monitoring strategy must be developed in accordance with a recognised Standard, such as CIBSE TM39 Building Energy Metering. The monitoring strategy must include a metering schedule and identify the location and types of meters.

The monitoring system must raise an alarm when the energy or water use increases beyond certain parameters and automatically issue an instant alert to the facilities manager. The process to assess, correct and validate alerts or faults must be detailed and contained in an accessible location.

The project team must demonstrate the reporting and alarm functionality has been designed, installed, commissioned, and tested at practical completion to be awarded this credit. System capability for future implementation is not sufficient.

#### 3.0.2 Commissioning and Tuning

The project team must perform the following

* Prior to construction:
  * Set environmental performance targets
  * Perform a services and maintainability review
  * Design for airtightness
* During construction and practical completion:
  * Commission the building
  * Engage building tuning service provider
  * Test for airtightness
* After practical completion:
  * Tune the building over the next 12 months

#### *Environmental performance targets and information*

At design, the project team must set and document environmental performance targets for the project outlining:

* The targets for the project energy and water consumption for each individual nominated building system
* Metering diagrams for energy and water
* Operational monitoring expectations of energy, water, and indoor environment quality
* Descriptions of the functions, intended operation, and maintenance requirements of individual nominated building systems
* Airtightness targets

Examples of common methods for demonstrating compliance with this is through the development (early in the design phase) of a design intent report or an owner's project requirements (OPR) document. The document must provide a clear description of the basic functions, operations, and maintenance of the nominated building systems. It lists targets for the project energy and water consumption for all individual nominated building systems.

All targets must be signed off by the asset owner.

#### *Services and maintainability review*

During design, the project team must conduct a services and maintainability review of the building. The review must include all project team roles involved within the design process i.e. Owner's Representative, Design consultants, Architect, ESD Consultant, Facilities Manager, Head Contractor and the Independent Commissioning Agent (where nominated).

The review must address the following:

* Commissionability
* Controllability
* Maintainability
* Operability
* Safety of all systems.

The services and maintainability review and its outcomes must be summarised in a 'Service and Maintainability Report'. All items must be addressed, closed-out and documented within the final Services and Maintainability Report and signed off by all involved parties prior to tender.

#### *Building commissioning*

During construction and before practical completion, all building systems must be commissioned per a recognised commissioning standard (CIBSE or ASHRAE commissioning guides). A commissioning specification must be included in the construction documentation listing requirements for each system.

A commissioning plan must be developed prior to practical completion.

The contractual tender or construction documentation must list the commissioning requirements for each system. It is not enough to state that systems must be commissioned to the relevant standard. The person responsible for the commissioning of the nominated services must have specific and demonstrable knowledge of the types of systems to be commissioned.

#### *Airtightness*

Airtightness must be included as part of the commissioning process during the following stages:

* Schematic design: review of design including an air barrier system schematic
* Design Development: review for tightness including air barrier continuity on building plans, sections, and details. Scope of work and necessary coordination between trades and responsibilities must be demonstrated
* Pre-Construction: A plan for stages of commissioning for air tightness must be defined and included in the project timeline
* Construction: The building must undertake airtightness testing in accordance with the pre-construction phase air-tightness testing plan. Testing must be carried out by a suitably qualified practitioner. If a quantitative test to determine an air permeability rate is used, it must be conducted on the whole building system according to AS/NZS ISO 9972:2015 Thermal performance of buildings determination of air permeability of buildings - Fan pressurisation method. On sections smaller than the whole building qualitative procedures such as ASTM E1186-17 may be used.

#### *Building systems tuning*

The owner or developer must contractually commit to a tuning process that includes quarterly adjustments and measurements for at least the first 12 months after occupation.

The commitment must include:

* A building tuning manual or plan
* A description of the building tuning team
* Confirmation the owner has engaged parties to tune the nominated systems
* Roles & responsibilities of each party within the tuning team, including deliverables
* The building tuning plan can be detailed within the commissioning plan. Where the tuning plan or manual is separate to the commissioning plan, it must refer to using the commissioning plan and the commissioning records & results as the baseline data.

The building tuning team must include:

* The facilities manager
* The Independent Commissioning Agent (ICA) or other building owner's representative
* The head contractor
* The services design professionals

These individuals must be available to address specific tuning issues where required.

#### 3.0.3 Building Information

#### *Operations and maintenance information*

The project team must provide operations and maintenance information for all nominated building systems to the building owner (or designated representative). This means:

* Appropriate content for all nominated building systems has been developed and provided
* The appropriate user group has access to the information they require to deliver best practice environmental outcomes
* Guidance on keeping information up to date is provided to the facilities management team in these documents

#### *Building logbook*

The project team must develop a building logbook to present to the building owner (or designated representative) before practical completion of the project. The building logbook must:

* Be developed in line with CIBSE TM31: Building Logbook Toolkit
* Cover all nominated building systems
* Include links or references to all relevant operations and maintenance information

#### *Building user information*

Building user information is a source of up-to-date, relevant information for the building user.

Building user information must be able to be updated and edited by the facilities management team, or other appropriate stakeholder groups, to ensure it remains current and relevant to users throughout the life of the building.

All building user information must be available to the building owner and facilities management team at the time of practical completion.

### <mark style="color:$success;">Credit Achievement</mark>

In addition to the Minimum Expectation, the project must comply with one of the following criteria:

* Soft Landings Approach
* Independent Commissioning Agent

For buildings with a Total Building Services Value of over $20m, both requirements must be met.

#### 3.1.1 Independent Commissioning Agent

An ICA must be appointed to advise, monitor, and verify the commissioning and tuning of the nominated building systems throughout the design, tender, construction, commissioning, and tuning phases.

The specified commissioning requirements must be overseen by a qualified independent commissioning professional(s).

#### 3.1.2 Soft Landings Approach

The soft landings approach is described in 'The Soft Landings Framework Australia and New Zealand' published by CIBSE ANZ, based on the BSRIA guide.

* The soft landings framework has five parts:
  * Briefing (Stage 1)
  * Design development (Stage 2)
  * Pre-handover (Stage 3)
  * Initial after care (Stage 4)
  * Years 1 to 3 aftercare (Stage 5)

Stages 1 to 4 are required for purposes of this credit. Stage 5 is optional, but highly encouraged.

The Soft Landings Framework document contains sample worksheets. Project teams are required to fill them in for Stage 1 to 3. Project teams are required to describe the actions that will be taken for Stage 4.

The facilities management team (or building owner's representative) for the building must be involved in the soft landings approach. This means, the facilities management team must:

* Be involved in commissioning and handover process
* Take part in the development of a brief technical guide for the building and the building operations and maintenance manual
* Sign-off on the operations and maintenance manual
* Be trained before handover. The training must include a demonstration of the building management system and any control mechanisms. The demonstration must be comprehensive and allow for additional items to be developed, such as logbooks or other manuals.

The facilities management team must have continued access to critical design and construction team members for two years after practical completion to allow for transitioning the responsibility for the building.

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Alternative pathways</mark>&#x20;

Where there are alternative pathways that a project can follow to achieve the credit, or sector specific alternatives.&#x20;

These were previously referred to as *Frequently Asked Questions*.&#x20;

<details>

<summary>Alternative pathways</summary>

</details>

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Clarifications</mark>

Where GBCA have clarified any requirements of the credit criteria. This information is additional and it is not complusory to apply.

These were previously referred to as *Frequently Asked Questions*.&#x20;

<details>

<summary>Clarifications</summary>

</details>

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Submission content</mark>

#### Submissions for this credit must contain:

* **Submission form** through Green Star Online
* **Evidence** to support claims made in the submission

#### Recommended evidence:

**Metering and Monitoring**

* Plan drawings showing the location of all energy and water meters in the project and the associated energy and water uses
* Schematic drawings, which are clearly coordinated with the plan drawings and the metering plan demonstrating adequate meter coverage and appropriate calculations or check mechanisms to allow provision of reporting and error detection as per the credit compliance requirements
* Letter of confirmation from the contractor/metering provider/manager demonstrating that the metering systems are continually and automatically monitored by a system that is able to produce alerts if any inaccuracies are found
* Commissioning reports demonstrating correct operation of meter reading, reporting and alarm generation
* Copy of Monitoring Strategy document specific to the building, including calculations demonstrating that all significant water and energy sources and uses are adequately covered in terms of both usage and accuracy verification
* Accuracy certificates for meters
* Completed Metering Validation sheets/documents to demonstrate metering system meets the NABERS Protocol for validation of non-utility meters

**Commissioning and Tuning**

* Service and Maintainability Report, where the service and maintainability review is summarised
* Extract(s) from the Commissioning Report demonstrating that comprehensive pre-commissioning activities and commissioning activities have been performed
* Building Tuning Commitment or contract demonstrating that there is a requirement for a building tuning process
* Building airtightness testing report detailing of test methodology, air flow rates, details of airtightness considerations from schematic design through to construction and statement that the target air permeability from Environmental Performance Targets has been achieved
* Signed confirmation from the testing practitioner and main contractor that the results have been sighted.

**Building Information**

* Owner's project requirements document, or an equivalent document, defining the nominated building systems
* Operations and maintenance information
* Building logbook
* Building user information.

**Soft Landings Approach**

* Evidence of implementation of BSRIA framework.

**Independent Commissioning Agent**

* CV of the Independent Commissioning Agent detailing the qualifications and experience relevant to the project
* Letter from building owner confirming the appointment of an ICA
* Evidence of implementation of BSRIA framework.

Alternate documentation can also be used by project teams to demonstrate compliance.

Refer to the [Guidance for Submitting for Designed Assessments](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/other-useful-resources/guidance-for-submitting-for-designed-assessments.md) for further information on submitting evidence for the Designed assessment.

The key requirement is that evidence is provided to support each claim made within the Submission form.

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Guidance</mark>

**Air tightness commissioning**\
The commissioning process for airtightness should be applied to the whole building or project. The requirement of this credit is to integrate attention to air tightness into the commissioning process and conduct testing to learn as much about the process as possible. The project team should set reasonable goals and verify that those goals have been met.

The following is provided as reference only and are not additional requirements.

* Pre-design phase: the process of commissioning for airtightness begins at the project inception, when broad expectations and goals for performance are defined. As a minimum, goals for performance should be linked or comparable to best practice guidelines such as ATTMA TSL1 and 2.
* At schematic design phase: This includes creation of an air barrier system schematic, definitions of different space conditioning requirements, and delineation of the extent of the conditioned building envelope. This process should fit in the same timeline with other such building envelope commissioning steps, such as definition of fire separation boundaries in the building.
* Design development phase: review for air tightness should be completed. The air barrier system includes façade elements, but also interior separations between conditioned and unconditioned spaces, and integration of HVAC, electrical, communications, and plumbing elements into the system. This includes plan reviews for air barrier continuity on building plans, sections, and details. To be considered:
  * Constructability and construction sequence
  * Costs of completion of the air barrier system
  * Scope of work and necessary coordination between trades and responsibilities
  * A plan for stages of commissioning for air tightness should be defined and included in the project timeline
* Pre-construction phase: builder and mechanical contractor statements of understanding and commitment of resources and personnel necessary for, and commitment to assist with, airtightness test preparation, regardless of scale of planned testing. Tests should be carried out according to the commissioning plan
* Verification phase: the aim of the airtightness testing is to verify the air permeability targets. The testing should verify the as-built performance of the building envelope. Should there be a discrepancy, the project team should address this as part of the commissioning process.

**Testing for airtightness**\
Airtightness testing should be carried out on the whole building, or across sample areas of the whole building by a suitably qualified practitioner. Testing should be completed on a total of either 5,000m2 or 20% of the building's envelope area, whichever is greater. Sample areas tested should be representative of the range of external envelope constructions, including different façade types, junctions and building geometries. Priorities should be placed on typical assemblies as well as critical, or high-risk, assemblies. Project teams conducting partial testing should do so prior to the envelope being fully completed, to provide early indication of weak points and allow time to address any issues identified during the testing process. Such tests may be considered qualitative and evaluate the effectiveness of the air barrier system. Nearer project completion, a quantitative test such as a AS/NZS ISO 9972:2015 on a whole building may also be used. For any testing conducted, documentation of deficiencies should be distributed to the project team, included in the commissioning report, and signed off by the design team.

**Suitably qualified practitioner**\
For the purposes of this credit element, a suitably qualified practitioner is defined as a member of the Air Tightness Testing and Measurement Association (ATTMA) or a testing member of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Association of Australia (AIVAA). Please note, there are different membership types within AIVAA – in order for this requirement to be met, the practitioner must be a 'testing member' or hold an ATTMA Level 2 Registered Air Tightness Tester certification. This requirement is intended to ensure a quality testing outcome given the testing practitioner's membership with an industry recognised body. Should project teams wish to demonstrate an alternative yet equivalent qualification, a Technical Question must be submitted.

For a current listing of members, please visit the following websites:

Air Tightness Testing and Measurement Association: <https://www.bcta.group/attma/>\
Air Infiltration and Ventilation Association of Australia

GBCA also recommends project teams refer to guidance published by the ABCB in regard to practitioners qualified to sign off JV3 reports.

**CIBSE TM39 Building Energy Metering standard**\
Although this Standard has been created to be used for developing energy metering and monitoring strategies, for the purpose of this credit, the same principles described in the Standard shall be used for developing water metering and monitoring strategies.

**Operational monitoring expectations**

* Energy: Performance measurement procedures including quarterly reporting against targets
* Water: Performance measurement procedures including quarterly reporting against targets
* Indoor Environment Quality: can be via occupant comfort survey targets, HVAC system maintenance targets, quarterly reporting of indoor air quality, thermal comfort, or lighting comfort performance measurements

**Metering schedule**\
The schedule should address the estimated loads for energy and water and list:

* Incoming input (electricity, gas, water etc)
* End Use (lighting, HVAC)
* Estimated energy consumption for the end use
* Which meters provide the required information
* Initial estimated end consumption

**Soft landings**\
For information on how to implement a "Soft Landings' approach, please see <https://www.bsria.com/uk/consultancy/project-improvement/soft-landings/?srsltid=AU7gw4WBqrHUhQKF2cbvuBoxRwbFFEb96l9ef54M8WgODlqa5hy7gNbl>

**Metering - cold shell spaces**\
Where base building metering and monitoring strategy relies on connection of tenant meters guidance must be created for tenants regarding metering requirements, including rules for connection of meters and programming of monitoring systems. Project teams to demonstrate this guidance has been created for tenants in leasing documentation.

**Monitoring systems – cold shell spaces**\
Where base building metering and monitoring strategy relies on connection of tenant meters guidance must be created for tenants regarding metering requirements, including rules for connection of meters and programming of monitoring systems. Project teams to demonstrate this guidance has been created for tenants in leasing documentation.

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Definitions</mark>

[Glossary](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/all-definitions.md#automatic-monitoring-system)

[Glossary](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/all-definitions.md#independent-commissioning-agent)

[Glossary](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/all-definitions.md#small-buildings)

[Glossary](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/all-definitions.md#air-barrier-system-schematic)

[Glossary](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/all-definitions.md#owners-project-requirements)

[Glossary](https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/all-definitions.md#building-services)

***

## <mark style="color:$primary;">Supporting information</mark>

The following resources support this credit:

* AIRAH DA27 Building Commissioning 2011
* AIRAH DA28 Building Management and Control Systems (BMCS) 2011
* ASHRAE Commissioning Guideline 1.1-2007 (for mechanical services)
* ASHRAE Guideline 0-2005
* AS/NZS ISO 9972:2015 Thermal performance of buildings – Determination of air permeability of buildings – Fan pressurisation method
* ASTM E779-10 Standard test method for determining air leakage rate by fan pressurisation
* ATTMA TSL1 Residential Dwellings – September 2016
* ATTMA TSL2 Non-Dwellings – October 2010
* CIBSE Commissioning Code M (and the ancillary codes for relevant services)
* CIBSE ANZ Soft Landings Framework, <https://www.cibse.org/get-involved/regions/australia-new-zealand>
* NIBS Guideline 3-2012 National Institute of Building Sciences Building Enclosure Commissioning Process BECx
* WTS001\_Softlanding-Brochure\_FA-LR.pdf.aspx
* Green Star Verification and Handover Guide
* 'Validating Non-Utility Meters for NABERS ratings' protocol, issued by the NSW Office of Environment and Heritage
* BSRIA Soft Landings Framework
* SA TA 5342:2021 Standards Australia Technical Specification for Building Commissioning


---

# Agent Instructions
This documentation is published with GitBook. GitBook is the documentation platform designed so that both humans and AI agents can read, navigate, and reason over technical content effectively. Learn more at gitbook.com.

## Querying This Documentation
If you need additional information that is not directly available in this page, you can query the documentation by asking a question.

Perform an HTTP GET request on the following URL with the `ask` and `goal` query parameters:

```
GET https://greenstarresources.gbca.au/greenstarresources.gbca.au_ratingtools/current-green-star-rating-tools/green-star-buildings/v1.0-rev-c/categories-and-credits/responsible/3-or-verification-and-handover.md?ask=<question>&goal=<user_goal>
```

`ask` is the immediate question: it should be specific, self-contained, and written in natural language.
`goal` is what the user is ultimately trying to achieve, the reason they need the answer. Sharing it helps GitBook give you a better, more relevant answer. A goal is most helpful when it describes the outcome the user wants rather than restating the question. For example, with `ask=how do I create an API token`, a goal like `automate deployments from our CI pipeline` lets GitBook tailor the answer to that use case.

The response will contain a direct answer to the question and relevant excerpts and sources from the documentation.

Use this mechanism when the answer is not explicitly present in the current page, you need clarification or additional context, or you want to retrieve related documentation sections.
